If corned beef and reubens are calling your name, Greater Peoria has plenty of spots ready to deliver. From classic Irish pubs and neighborhood taverns to local delis and meat markets, you’ll find stacked sandwiches, hearty plates, and all the comforting flavors that make this combo a favorite well beyond St. Patrick’s Day.
Authentic Irish Spots
Peoria is home to several authentic Irish pubs that offer a taste of Ireland right here in the Midwest. These establishments serve up classic corned beef and cabbage, hearty reubens, and festive atmospheres that make you feel like you’re celebrating St. Patrick’s Day no matter the season.
Carrigan’s Pub in East Peoria – A cozy neighborhood pub with Irish-inspired charm, Carrigan’s serves up a classic reuben stacked with corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island on rye. It’s a great pick for anyone craving a no-frills, satisfying pub sandwich.
Donnelly’s Irish Pub in Peoria – Peoria’s oldest traditional Irish pub is a go-to destination for St. Patrick’s Day. Their famous corned beef dinner and classic reuben sandwich keep the crowds coming. No phone orders on the big day—arrive early and soak in the festive atmosphere!
Jimmy’s Bar in West Peoria – This longtime local favorite brings plenty of Irish spirit to the table, and their reuben is a worthy addition to the list. With sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island on marble rye, it’s an easy choice for a classic corned beef fix.
Kelleher’s Irish Pub + Eatery Downtown Peoria – Located on the riverfront, this lively pub is an essential stop for St. Patrick’s Day revelers. Start your day with an Irish breakfast, enjoy live music and dancing, and grab a plate of corned beef and cabbage under their heated outdoor tent.
Kenny’s Westside Pub in Downtown Peoria – Born on St. Patrick’s Day, this downtown staple opens at 9 AM for biscuits and gravy before rolling out corned beef and cabbage all day. Expect live music, great drinks, and a full day of celebration.
W.E. Sullivan’s Irish Pub + Fare in Peoria Heights – Doors open early for breakfast, and the party continues all day with corned beef, cabbage, and a street festival featuring live music, drinks, and a lively crowd.
Other Great Locations
The Peoria area has plenty of great spots for corned beef and Reuben sandwiches. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual meal, a cozy bistro, or a lively pub, these local favorites serve up the classic flavors you’re craving.
Brasky’s Bar + Grill in Peoria – Their signature reuben on marbled rye is a fan favorite, but on St. Patrick’s Day, the menu expands to include traditional corned beef and cabbage, along with plenty of green beer.
The Fox Pub & Cafe in Peoria – While more British than Irish, The Fox earns a spot thanks to its Pub Reuben and house-made Corned Beef Bap. If you want a classic pub atmosphere with a strong corned beef option, this is an easy add.
The Publik House in Peoria Heights – Known for their mouthwatering reuben sandwich, this cozy bistro also offers a deep beer and wine selection to complement your meal.
One World Café in Peoria – Known for its diverse menu and cozy atmosphere, One World Café serves up a delicious reuben sandwich alongside an eclectic mix of international and American cuisine.
Slow Hand Craft BBQ - Seasonal Item in Peoria Heights – Smoked corned beef gives their reuben a unique BBQ twist. Pair it with live music in Heritage Square for a memorable meal.
Schooners in Peoria Heights – A local favorite for hearty pub fare, Schooners is famous for its generous portions and welcoming atmosphere. Their reuben is a must-try for sandwich lovers.
Hidden Gems + Unique Twists
If you’re looking for a creative take on classic corned beef items or an out of the way spot to enjoy one, Peoria has several hidden gems that offer exciting variations. These spots serve up Irish-inspired fare with a delicious twist, whether you’re looking for a traditional or pickle reuben.
Silver Bullet in East Peoria – Their Reuben Sandwich is a must-try! A perfectly grilled marble rye melt filled with corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and their homemade 1000 Island dressing makes this sandwich a standout.
Castle Patio Inn in Peoria – A hidden gem with a rich history, Castle Patio Inn is known for its welcoming atmosphere and excellent food. Stop in for a delicious reuben and enjoy the laid-back vibe
Castaway’s Bar + Grill in Chillicothe – At Castaways, every visit feels like a celebration! With a welcoming and friendly atmosphere, it’s the perfect place to unwind, whether you’re coming off a big win or just looking for a no-frills diner for the whole family. Don’t miss their delicious original or pickle reuben sandwich.
Silver Dollar Tavern in Peoria Heights – A longtime favorite for St. Pat’s Day revelers, this historic tavern offers a lively atmosphere, cold drinks, and a classic Irish-American menu.
Take-Home Irish Feasts
If you’d rather enjoy a traditional Irish meal from the comfort of home, Peoria has several butcher shops and delis that offer high-quality corned beef and prepared meals. Whether you’re looking for a fully cooked dinner or just the ingredients to make your own, these spots have you covered.
Alwan & Sons Meat Co. in Peoria Heights – Offering complete corned beef brisket dinners with all the fixings, as well as hot reuben sandwiches to go. Pre-orders are highly recommended!
Pottstown Meat & Deli in Peoria – Whether you want to cook your own corned beef at home or grab a fully prepared dinner, Pottstown has you covered. Try their New York Reuben, featuring corned beef, Swiss cheese, and sauerkraut served on toasted pumpernickel rye bread.
You must be logged in to post a comment.